
The Upper Tribunal has ruled that the Home Secretary can lawfully deprive an individual of their British citizenship without prior notice, particularly if there is a concern that the person might renounce their second nationality. Such renunciation could render the deprivation of British citizenship unlawful by leaving the individual stateless. This ruling was made in the case of Kolicaj (Deprivation: procedure and discretion) Albania UKUT 294 (IAC). In this case, the appellant was informed of their citizenship deprivation on the same day they were notified that it was under review due to a criminal conviction.
The headnote summarises the decision as follows:
- Procedural fairness requirements are highly fact-sensitive but generally necessitate that the Secretary of State notifies an individual that she is considering depriving them of their citizenship, allowing them an opportunity to make representations. However, the Secretary of State may lawfully bypass this step if there is a proper reason to believe the individual would try to obstruct the process upon receiving such notification.
- When the Secretary of State seeks to deprive someone of British citizenship under section 40(2) of the British Nationality Act 1981, she may lawfully omit the ‘minded-to’ step if there is a clear and significant risk that the individual would renounce any other citizenship to make themselves stateless, thus engaging the statelessness proviso in section 40(4).
- If the Secretary of State determines that the conditions for exercising this power are met, she must then use her discretion to decide whether to deprive the person of their British citizenship, considering all the circumstances of the case. This means that even if the Secretary of State’s decision regarding the initial condition is legally sound, the overall decision could still be unlawful if she fails to properly exercise her discretion or if the exercise of that discretion is flawed by public law error.
In this case, the appeal was allowed not due to the lack of notice but because of inadequacies in the Home Secretary’s explanation of her discretionary use in making the deprivation decision. As a result, an appeal against the findings on the need to provide notice and an opportunity to make representations may be unlikely. For now, the Home Secretary has been authorised to make deprivation decisions without prior notice, and it is conceivable that there may be an increase in such decisions.
All of our articles are intended for informational purposes only and do not constitute legal advice. It is recommended that specific professional advice is sought before acting on any of the information provided.

