No EU citizenship, no extended family members and the Brexit impacts

In Sabina Begum v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2021] EWCA Civ 1878 the Court of Appeal considered whether an extended family member, hoping to stay in the UK with their EEA citizen sponsor, can do so when the sponsor only acquired that citizenship after the extended family member entered the UK.

The answer is no, they can’t.

Direct and extended family members

Direct family members of European Economic Area nationals – such as spouses and children under the age of 21 – had an automatic right to enter and reside in the UK under EU free movement law. More distant family members – referred to as extended, or other, family members – did not have automatic rights. They had to make an application for a family permit or residence card. 

An extended family member could apply to enter, or stay in, the UK where they were dependent on a sponsoring relative with EEA citizenship. They must have been dependent before entering the UK (i.e., whilst still living in their country of origin).

Citizenship after entry

Sabina Begum, a national of Bangladesh, came to the UK in April 2010 as a university student, aged 22. She was supported by her uncle, who became an Italian citizen shortly after Ms Begum entered the UK. He paid for her education and upkeep in both Bangladesh and Britain. However, he was not an EEA citizen when Ms Begum was living in Bangladesh, or when she left Bangladesh and entered the UK.

It is therefore clear from the language of Article 3(2) [of the Free Movement Directive 2004/38] that if the dependency requirement is relied upon, the person claiming to be an extended family member must be dependent upon the sponsor in the country from which that person has come to the UK, at the time when they left that country to enter the UK.

For Ms Begum to be dependent on an EEA citizen before she left Bangladesh, her uncle needs to have been an EEA citizen at that time. As he wasn’t, the appeal failed.

No free movement rights to restrict

The object of EU free movement law is, as the name suggests, to enable free movement of EU citizens. The aim is not family reunification — albeit that “family reunion is an ancillary means by which free movement may be facilitated or promoted”.

The Home Office only needs to allow an extended family member to enter, or stay in, the UK where refusal would restrict the EEA citizen’s free movement rights.

This is often overlooked. Often an EEA citizen will only seek to bring an extended family member to the UK after they have lived here for several years. That makes it difficult to argue that their free movement rights, which they had exercised quite some time ago, will be restricted if their family member cannot now join them. 

The problem for Ms Begum was that her uncle had no free movement rights when she left Bangladesh, as he was not an EEA citizen. EU free movement law was not engaged. A person cannot be deterred from exercising rights that they do not have.

Ms Begum’s appeal was therefore refused.

What about Brexit?

Why does any of this matter after Brexit? The Court of Appeal provides three reasons.

Consideration of EU law may be necessary to ascertain whether a person enjoys (or potentially enjoys) rights under the Brexit Withdrawal Agreement.

A court deciding an appeal which concerns an application made before the end of the transition period, should generally do so by reference to the law in force before 11pm on 31 December 2020 — that is, when Brexit took full legal effect. EU free movement law has been preserved for certain specific purposes by “complex secondary legislation”.

Despite Brexit, cases invoking EU free movement law aren’t going away any time soon. They will become less frequent as cases which began before 31 December 2020 are resolved. But the preservation of EU free movement law for some purposes (such as deportation for offences committed before 31 December 2020), the link to the Withdrawal Agreement, and the numerous references to the EEA Regulations scattered throughout Appendix EU, mean that the courts will continue to grapple with EU law issues for several years to come.

Like this article? Share on

Facebook
Linkdin
Twitter
Telegram
WhatsApp

Related articles

Information about our own complaints process, raising concerns to the Legal Ombudsman and to us

We want to give you the best possible service. However, if at any point you become unhappy or concerned about the service we provided then you should inform us immediately, so that we can do our best to resolve the problem.

In the first instance it may be helpful to contact the person who is working on your case to discuss your concerns and we will do our best to resolve any issues at this stage. If you would like to make a formal complaint, then you can read our full complaints procedure here. Making a complaint will not affect how we handle your case.

The Solicitors Regulation Authority can help you if you are concerned about our behaviour. This could be for things like dishonesty, taking or losing your money or treating you unfairly because of your age, a disability or other characteristic. 

You can raise your concerns with the Solicitors Regulation Authority.

What do to if we cannot resolve your complaint

The Legal Ombudsman can help you if we are unable to resolve your complaint ourselves. They will look at your complaint independently and it will not affect how we handle your case.

Before accepting a complaint for investigation, the Legal Ombudsman will check that you have tried to resolve your complaint with us first. If you have, then you must take your complaint to the Legal Ombudsman:

  • Within six months of receiving our final response to your complaint; and,
  • Within one year of the date of the act or omission about which you are concerned; or
  • Within one year of you realising that there was a concern.

 

If you would like more information about the Legal Ombudsman, you can contact them at the following details:

 Contact details

This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. By closing this message, you consent to our cookies on this device in accordance with our cookie policy unless you have disabled them.