
Since the start of 2023, there has been a sharp rise in asylum claims being withdrawn. This process appears to have disproportionately affected Albanian nationals, with 14,371 claims being withdrawn in 2023 and 2024 alone, out of a total of 44,111.
While this proportion dropped somewhat in 2024, it remains significant. In 2024, 3,633 of the 17,810 withdrawn claims were from Albanians. The next largest group was from India, with 3,257 claims, followed by Vietnam (1,835) and Brazil (995). What remains unclear, however, is how many of these withdrawals are being reversed, as we’ve seen some successful legal challenges to withdrawal decisions (e.g., this Albanian case and this ruling by the Asylum Support Tribunal).
A National Audit Office report from June 2023 highlighted a concerning trend: many of these “withdrawals” are actually what lawyers refer to as non-compliance refusals. Essentially, asylum seekers who failed to return a form on time, missed an appointment, or something similar. Some asylum seekers might genuinely have disappeared, but experience suggests the Home Office struggles with keeping up-to-date records on address changes, and often sends correspondence to the wrong address. It’s likely that a proportion of these withdrawals are simply mistakes.
This creates a significant long-term problem. Many individuals whose claims are marked as “withdrawn” are still in the UK and will reappear eventually. They may challenge the withdrawal decision through judicial review or an appeal to the Asylum Support Tribunal, or they may make a fresh asylum claim. These cases become more complex and resource-intensive to process. It’s entirely possible that, in the long run, the Home Office is only adding to its workload by prioritising short-term targets over accuracy.
Although the case papers may be removed from the backlog, the individuals behind those cases have not disappeared. At some point, their claims will need to be properly considered. In the meantime, with no legal rights, they are left vulnerable to exploitation as they struggle to survive.
What Happens to Newly Recognised Refugees?
In 2024, over 46,720 grants of asylum were made. These individuals moved from Home Office support to either independent living or support from their local authorities – though, in some cases, they simply fall through the cracks and end up homeless.
After years of enforced unemployment, it’s no surprise that many refugees struggle to find work in the brief window of time the Home Office gives them between receiving their new immigration papers (or eVisa) and being evicted from asylum accommodation. Refugees are given just 28 days to find employment, secure pay, and arrange accommodation. This is an impossible task. The short timeframe also makes it difficult for refugees to get the support they need from local authorities. As a result, local authorities are now scrambling to house thousands of refugees with very little notice.
The recent pilot to extend this period to 56 days is a step in the right direction, although the Home Office seems to be tying this extension to the problematic rollout of the eVisa, which could eat into those extra days.
Unfortunately, there will always be those who argue that refugees becoming homeless proves they are a drain on public resources. But if we delay granting them status, prevent them from working for years, and force them into remote accommodation, then fail to offer them enough notice or proper support when they finally get recognised, it’s hardly surprising they struggle to integrate into society.
Local authorities urgently need more funding, and the central government must allow refugees to work if they’ve been waiting for over six months. There should also be a longer notice period before they are evicted, along with a comprehensive integration package that could include language lessons and career training.
Asylum Appeals Are on the Rise
In 2022, 76% of initial asylum decisions made by the Home Office were grants of protection – a historic high. However, the grant rate has since dropped, and in 2024, it stands at just 47%, which signals an underlying problem.
It’s also worth noting that the Home Office calculates this grant rate by only considering grants and refusals, excluding cases marked as withdrawn or with “administrative outcomes.” When those are included, the actual grant rate drops to 39%.
With a greater number of asylum decisions being made, the number of refusals has naturally risen too, reaching 44,433 in 2024. This surge has led to an increase in the number of asylum appeals lodged, with 36,552 appeals received by the First-tier Tribunal in 2024, up from 21,339 in 2023.
We can expect the success rate of these appeals to rise because of the poor quality of many of the initial decisions. However, due to the lengthy appeals process, the impact of these changes won’t be seen immediately. The increasing number of unrepresented appellants will likely lower the overall success rate, though this will be hard to quantify.
The backlog at the tribunal is growing. In the final quarter of 2024, it took an average of 48 weeks for the First-tier Tribunal to decide an asylum case, up from 39 weeks earlier in the year. Unfortunately, the resources available to handle this increase in cases have not kept pace, and there are now fewer lawyers available to take on asylum cases due to the low pay offered by legal aid.
Even before the rise in appeals, around half of asylum seekers were unable to find a legal aid lawyer, and this proportion is set to rise. While a recent announcement to increase funding for legal aid lawyers is welcome, it will take time to see any significant improvement.
The lack of lawyers means many asylum seekers are left unrepresented. This not only results in unfairness and potential bad outcomes but also leads to further delays. It takes much longer for judges to process appeals when the appellant does not have legal representation.
Refusal ≠ Removal
In recent years, we’ve seen a reversal of the long-term downward trend in asylum removals. In part, this is due to the increase in refusals as the number of claims rises.
In 2021, there were only 346 enforced asylum returns, and in 2022, 580. But by 2023, this number had increased to 1,997, and in 2024, to 2,647.
In 2024, there were 44,433 asylum refusals, though not all will result in immediate removal. Refugees who have had their claims rejected have the right to appeal, and the removal process can take some time.
Despite the rise in refusals, the reality is that even those whose asylum claims are denied are likely to remain in the UK long-term. Over the past five years, there have been 96,910 asylum refusals, but only 21,418 enforced or voluntary returns.
Immigration Detention
The use of immigration detention has decreased in recent years, but the percentage of those in detention who are asylum seekers has steadily increased, peaking again in 2024.
Immigration detention is meant to be used for those who are to be removed from the UK. However, the number of detainees actually being removed has decreased significantly since 2010. The majority of detainees are now released into the community.
This raises questions about whether detention is the right approach, particularly when it costs around £90 per day to detain a person. If detention is not leading to removal, then it may not be serving its intended purpose.
Given the limited capacity of detention centres and the growing number of failed asylum seekers, it is clear that detention is unlikely to be a viable long-term solution.
Resettlement and Safe Routes
The government likes to talk about safe and legal routes to reach the UK, but the reality is that, unless you’re Ukrainian or from Hong Kong, these routes are very limited.
In the year to September 2024, 7,081 refugees were resettled through Afghan schemes, and just 2,529 through the general UK resettlement scheme. There is no “queue” to jump – refugees are selected by the UNHCR and have no say in where they’re resettled.
While there has been some success in resettling refugees from Ukraine and Hong Kong, the reality is that the UK is not offering the safe and legal routes that many other countries provide.
What Needs to Be Done?
The UK’s asylum system is undeniably broken, and much of the blame lies with the Conservative government. Their policies, such as the Illegal Migration Act and the Rwanda scheme, have worsened the situation.
The good news is that things seem to be stabilising, but there are still major issues to address. The Home Office must focus on improving the quality of its decisions and addressing the growing backlog in the appeals process. We need a system that prioritises people over numbers, making the right decision the first time, rather than treating asylum claims as a box-ticking exercise.
The introduction of measures like allowing asylum seekers to work after six months, extending the notice period before eviction, and providing better integration packages would make a real difference.
The asylum system is not beyond repair, but it needs urgent reform. It’s time to focus on proper decision-making, prioritising resources where they are most needed, and ensuring that asylum seekers are treated with dignity and respect.

